| | | Moravian won the toss and deferred |
| | | Muhlenberg will receive and defend the west goal |
| | | Ian Heck kickoff 63 yards to the MUHL7, Chase Nadell return 25 yards to the MUHL32 (D Protasiewicz). |
| H | 1-10 | H32 | Codie Bender rush right for loss of 1 yard to the MUHL31 (M McClarin). |
| H | 2-11 | H31 | Dan Deighan rush right for 2 yards to the MUHL33, out-of-bounds (Daniel Burley). |
| H | 3-9 | H33 | Dan Deighan rush left for 1 yard to the MUHL34, out-of-bounds (Jayson Williams). |
| H | 4-8 | H34 | Jason LoPipero punt 21 yards to the MOR45, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 02:08 |
| V | 1-10 | V45 | MORAVIAN drive start at 12:52 (1st). |
| V | 1-10 | V45 | Steve Panasuk pass complete to Shawn Sylvainus for 11 yards to the MUHL44, 1ST DOWN MOR (Jake Floyd). |
| V | 1-10 | H44 | Mike Zanoni rush up middle for 3 yards to the MUHL41 (Frank Emmett). |
| V | 2-7 | H41 | Ryan Rempe rush up middle for 4 yards to the MUHL37 (Andy Curley). |
| V | 3-3 | H37 | Steve Panasuk pass incomplete to Albie Moran. |
| V | 4-3 | H37 | E Dziengelski punt 37 yards to the MUHL0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 18 yards, TOP 01:36 |
| H | 1-10 | H20 | MUHLENBERG drive start at 11:16 (1st). |
| H | 1-10 | H20 | Dan Deighan pass complete to Phil Cresta for 16 yards to the MUHL36, 1ST DOWN MUHL (David Wacker). |
| H | 1-10 | H36 | Codie Bender rush left for no gain to the MUHL36 (Evan Bauer). |
| H | 2-10 | H36 | Dan Deighan pass complete to Steve Liparini for 14 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN MUHL (Daniel Burley). |
| H | 1-10 | H50 | Codie Bender rush left for 1 yard to the MOR49 (Jake Hildebrand;Travis King). |
| H | 2-9 | V49 | Dan Deighan sacked for loss of 2 yards to the MUHL49 (Evan Bauer). |
| H | 3-11 | H49 | Dan Deighan sacked for loss of 1 yard to the MUHL48 (Jake Hildebrand). |
| H | 4-12 | H48 | Jason LoPipero punt 38 yards to the MOR14, Travis King return 13 yards to the MOR27 (P. McDonough). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 28 yards, TOP 03:29 |
| V | 1-10 | V27 | MORAVIAN drive start at 07:47 (1st). |
| V | 1-10 | V27 | Ryan Rempe rush left for 2 yards to the MOR29 (Scott Lissner;P. McDonough). |
| V | 2-8 | V29 | Shawn Sylvainus rush right for 6 yards to the MOR35 (Ewan Wright). |
| V | 3-2 | V35 | Ryan Rempe rush right for loss of 2 yards to the MOR33 (Jake Floyd). |
| V | 4-4 | V33 | E Dziengelski punt 37 yards to the MUHL30, Steve Nissley return 4 yards to the MUHL34 (Langston Ross). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:44 |
| H | 1-10 | H34 | MUHLENBERG drive start at 06:03 (1st). |
| H | 1-10 | H34 | Dan Deighan pass complete to Steve Liparini for 16 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN MUHL (Philip Bortz). |
| H | 1-10 | H50 | Dan Deighan pass complete to Bobby Bushong for 6 yards to the MOR44 (Jake Hildebrand). |
| H | 2-4 | V44 | Codie Bender rush right for 3 yards to the MOR41 (Anthony Carney). |
| H | 3-1 | V41 | Dan Deighan rush right for 2 yards to the MOR39, 1ST DOWN MUHL, out-of-bounds (Philip Bortz). |
| H | 1-10 | V39 | Dan Deighan sacked for loss of 1 yard to the MOR40 (Evan Bauer), PENALTY MUHL holding 10 yards to the MOR49, NO PLAY. |
| H | 1-20 | V49 | Codie Bender rush left for loss of 6 yards to the MUHL45 (Anthony Carney). |
| H | 2-26 | H45 | Dan Deighan pass incomplete to Steve Liparini. |
| H | 3-26 | H45 | Dan Deighan rush draw play for 16 yards to the MOR39 (Evan Bauer), PENALTY MUHL holding 10 yards to the MUHL35, NO PLAY. |
| H | 3-36 | H35 | T. Dandridge rush draw play for 13 yards to the MUHL48 (David Wacker). |
| H | 4-23 | H48 | Jason LoPipero punt 34 yards to the MOR18, fair catch by Travis King. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 14 yards, TOP 04:40 |
| V | 1-10 | V18 | MORAVIAN drive start at 01:23 (1st). |
| V | 1-10 | V18 | Ryan Rempe rush left for 2 yards to the MOR20 (P. McDonough). |
| V | 2-8 | V20 | Steve Panasuk pass incomplete to Albie Moran. |
| V | 3-8 | V20 | Ryan Rempe rush draw play for no gain to the MOR20. |
| V | 4-8 | V20 | E Dziengelski punt 35 yards to the MUHL45, Steve Nissley return 8 yards to the MOR47 (Tyler Potterton). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 01:23 |
| H | 1-10 | V47 | MUHLENBERG drive start at 00:00 (1st). |