| D | 4-15 | D31 | End of 1st half, clock 00:00. |
| D | 3-10 | D36 | Aaron Wilmer sacked for loss of 5 yards to the DVC31 (Ian Gimbar). |
| D | 2-10 | D36 | Aaron Wilmer pass incomplete to Ed Ferrell. |
| D | 1-10 | D36 | Aaron Wilmer pass incomplete to Rasheed Bailey. |
| D | 1-10 | D36 | DELAWARE VALLEY drive start at 00:31 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 29 yards, TOP 01:36 |
| M | 2-6 | D44 | Joe Carlucci pass intercepted by Cory Armstrong at the DVC35, Cory Armstrong return 1 yards to the DVC36 (T. Dandridge). |
| M | 2-6 | D44 | Timeout Muhlenberg, clock 00:43. |
| M | 1-10 | D48 | Joe Carlucci rush right for 4 yards to the DVC44 (Rashaad Lighty;Bernard Avery). |
| M | 3-2 | M46 | Joe Carlucci pass complete to Tyler George for 6 yards to the DVC48, 1ST DOWN MUHL (Brian Carter). |
| M | 2-2 | M46 | Joe Carlucci rush left for no gain to the MUHL46, out-of-bounds (Chris McCabe). |
| M | 1-10 | M38 | Joe Carlucci pass complete to T. Dandridge for 8 yards to the MUHL46 (T. Osborne). |
| M | 2-3 | M34 | T. Dandridge rush left for 4 yards to the MUHL38, 1ST DOWN MUHL (John Eberly). |
| M | 1-10 | M27 | T. Dandridge rush up middle for 7 yards to the MUHL34 (Chris McCabe). |
| M | 1-10 | M27 | MUHLENBERG drive start at 02:07 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:34 |
| D | 4-6 | D39 | Dave Faraldo punt 34 yards to the MUHL27, fair catch by John Gruver. |
| D | 3-6 | D39 | Aaron Wilmer pass incomplete to Rasheed Bailey, QB hurry by Jeremey Thomas. |
| D | 2-11 | D34 | Aaron Wilmer rush right for 5 yards to the DVC39 (J. Charles;Andrew Onimus). |
| D | 1-10 | D35 | Aaron Wilmer rush right for loss of 1 yard to the DVC34 (Kory Crichton). |
| D | 1-10 | D35 | DELAWARE VALLEY drive start at 03:41 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 28 yards, TOP 03:07 |
| M | 4-8 | D30 | Joe Carlucci sacked for loss of 5 yards to the DVC35 (Dwayne Shaw). |
| M | 3-11 | D33 | Joe Carlucci rush quarterback draw for 3 yards to the DVC30 (Dwayne Shaw;Kenner-English). |
| M | 2-10 | D32 | Joe Carlucci sacked for loss of 1 yard to the DVC33 (Chad Wisniewski). |
| M | 1-10 | D32 | Joe Carlucci pass incomplete to Michael Long. |
| M | 3-7 | D47 | Joe Carlucci pass complete to Tyler George for 15 yards to the DVC32, 1ST DOWN MUHL (T. Osborne). |
| M | 2-10 | M50 | T. Dandridge rush up middle for 3 yards to the DVC47 (Dwayne Shaw). |
| M | 1-10 | M50 | Joe Carlucci pass incomplete to Isaiah Vaughn. |
| M | 2-6 | M41 | Joe Carlucci pass complete to Isaiah Vaughn for 9 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN MUHL, out-of-bounds (Brian Carter). |
| M | 1-10 | M37 | T. Dandridge rush left for 4 yards to the MUHL41 (Dwayne Shaw;Shaquille Lee). |
| M | 1-10 | M37 | MUHLENBERG drive start at 06:48 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:17 |
| D | 4-8 | M37 | Aaron Wilmer pass incomplete to James Norton, QB hurry by Greg DeLade. |
| D | 3-8 | M37 | Aaron Wilmer pass incomplete to Dashown Waller. |
| D | 2-20 | M49 | Aaron Wilmer rush up middle to the MUHL40, fumble forced by Jeremey Thomas, fumble by Aaron Wilmer recovered by DVC TEAM at MUHL37. |
| D | 1-20 | M49 | Aaron Wilmer pass incomplete to Rasheed Bailey (Tim Vogel). |
| D | 1-10 | M39 | Kyle Schuberth rush up middle for 2 yards to the MUHL37 (Matt Johnson), PENALTY DVC holding 10 yards to the MUHL49, NO PLAY. |
| D | 1-10 | M39 | DELAWARE VALLEY drive start at 08:05 (2nd). |
| | | Michael Daniel kickoff 9 yards to the MUHL44, on-side kick, recovered by DVC on MUHL44, PENALTY MUHL offside 5 yards to the MUHL39, 1st and 10, DVC ball on MUHL39. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 57 yards, TOP 00:12 |
| | | Muhlenberg 14, Delaware Valley 10 |
| | | Connor Winter kick attempt good. |
| M | 1-10 | M43 | Joe Carlucci pass complete to Isaiah Vaughn for 57 yards to the DVC0, 1ST DOWN MUHL, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:07. |
| M | 1-10 | M43 | MUHLENBERG drive start at 08:19 (2nd). |
| | | punt tipped by Onimus |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:36 |
| D | 4-9 | D33 | Dave Faraldo punt 24 yards to the MUHL43, downed. |
| D | 3-4 | D38 | Aaron Wilmer sacked for loss of 5 yards to the DVC33 (Ian Gimbar;Greg DeLade). |
| D | 2-4 | D38 | Alquann Jones rush right for no gain to the DVC38 (Andrew Onimus). |
| D | 1-10 | D32 | Kyle Schuberth rush up middle for 6 yards to the DVC38 (Ian Gimbar). |
| D | 1-10 | D32 | DELAWARE VALLEY drive start at 09:55 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:47 |
| M | 4-9 | M27 | Connor Winter punt 41 yards to the DVC32, out-of-bounds. |
| M | 3-9 | M27 | Joe Carlucci pass incomplete to Tyler George. |
| M | 3-9 | M27 | Timeout Muhlenberg, clock 10:11. |
| M | 3-4 | M32 | PENALTY MUHL false start 5 yards to the MUHL27. |
| M | 2-8 | M28 | T. Dandridge rush up middle for 4 yards to the MUHL32 (Bernard Avery). |
| M | 1-10 | M26 | T. Dandridge rush up middle for 2 yards to the MUHL28 (Dwayne Shaw). |
| M | 1-10 | M26 | MUHLENBERG drive start at 11:42 (2nd). |
| | | Brandon Snyder kickoff 45 yards to the MUHL20, John Gruver return 6 yards to the MUHL26 (Kenner-English). |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 46 yards, TOP 07:27 |
| | | Delaware Valley 10, Muhlenberg 7 |
| D | 4-8 | M17 | Brandon Snyder field goal attempt from 34 GOOD, clock 11:46. |
| D | 4-8 | M17 | Timeout Muhlenberg, clock 11:52. |
| D | 3-18 | M27 | Aaron Wilmer pass complete to Lewis Vincent for 10 yards to the MUHL17 (Jeremey Thomas). |
| D | 3-8 | M17 | Aaron Wilmer pass complete to Ed Ferrell for 17 yards to the MUHL0, clock 12:24, PENALTY DVC holding 10 yards to the MUHL27, NO PLAY. |
| D | 2-8 | M17 | Alquann Jones rush right for no gain to the MUHL17 (Ian Gimbar). |
| D | 1-10 | M19 | Kyle Schuberth rush up middle for 2 yards to the MUHL17 (Matt Johnson). |
| D | 4-6 | M26 | Aaron Wilmer rush left for 7 yards to the MUHL19, 1ST DOWN DVC, out-of-bounds (Matt Pagano). |
| D | 3-7 | M27 | Aaron Wilmer rush left for 1 yard to the MUHL26 (Matt Pagano). |
| D | 3-7 | M27 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |