| Year | President |
|---|---|
| 1867-1876 | Frederick Augustus Muhlenberg |
| 1877-1885 | J.P. Benjamin Sadtler |
| 1886-1903 | Theodore Lorenzo Seip |
| 1904-1936 | John A.W. Haas |
| 1937-1951 | Levering Tyson |
| 1953-1961 | J. Conrad Seegers '13 |
| 1961-1969 | Erling N. Jensen |
| 1969-1984 | John H. Morey |
| 1984-1992 | Jonathan C. Messerli |
| 1992-2002 | Arthur R. Taylor |
| 2003-2015 | Peyton Randolph Helm |
| 2015-2019 | John I. Williams Jr. |
| 2019- | Kathleen E. Harring |